Wonder & Worry

Guidelines by field

AI guidelines in mental health and therapy what the field's own bodies ask

Mental health is the field where governments moved fastest from advice to outright bans, because the person on the other side of the screen is often vulnerable and the harm can be immediate. Psychologists' and counselors' associations, three US states and England's health service have all spoken.

Last reviewed 27 October 2026. Every claim links to its source.

At a glance

  1. Support, never replace

    AI can help a clinician, but it does not replace one.

  2. Informed consent

    Tell clients when AI is used, why, and what the benefits and risks are.

  3. The clinician owns every note

    Including AI-drafted ones. Nevada requires providers to review AI-generated notes and billing.

  4. No bot poses as a professional

    A chatbot must never present itself as a licensed therapist.

  5. Extra care for the young and people in crisis

    Design should avoid unhealthy dependence, and clinicians should ask clients whether they use chatbots.

Who has spoken

AI should augment, not replace, human decision-making.

American Psychological Association

Binding and voluntary

Binding

State laws in Illinois, Nevada and Utah. Professional ethics codes can be enforced through licensing boards, though the AI guidance itself is advisory.

Voluntary

APA and ACA guidance and NHS public-health statements. Companion-chatbot laws aimed at minors are on the children and families page.

What changed in 2025 and 2026

Where people still disagree

States disagree on the remedy: Illinois and Nevada ban AI-delivered therapy, while Utah allows mental-health chatbots under disclosure and data rules.

Questions to ask yourself

  • Does my client know, in plain words, which parts of their care or records involved AI?
  • If a client in crisis used this tool at 2 a.m., what would it do, and would I be comfortable with that?
  • Am I using AI in a way my state now prohibits, such as letting it shape treatment decisions?

How this lines up with my everyday guidelines

My everyday guidelines beside this field's nearest rules
My everyday guidelinesThe field's nearest rule

1. Maintain your expertise Use AI to enhance your judgment, not replace it.

AI should augment, not replace, human decision-making (APA).

4. Use for good Never use AI to deceive, manipulate or harm others.

A chatbot must never pose as a licensed professional (APA advisory; Nevada AB 406).

7. Model healthy use for the family Show children how to think critically about AI responses.

Extra protection for children, teens and people in crisis (APA advisory).

Source 213

American Psychological Association. Ethical guidance for AI in the professional practice of health service psychology. Jun 2025, updated Dec 2025. apa.org/topics/artificial-intelligence-machine-learning/ethical-guidance-ai-professional-practice

See all sources

Source 215

American Counseling Association. AI can support, not replace, human counselors, according to new recommendations. 25 Jan 2024. counseling.org/publications/media-center/article/2024/01/25/ai-can-support-not-replace-human-counselors-according-to-new-recommendations ; Recommendations for client use and caution of AI. counseling.org/resources/research-reports/artificial-intelligence-counseling/recommendations-for-client-use-and-caution-of-artificial-intelligence

See all sources

Source 217

CASRAI (summary). AI therapy laws: Illinois, Nevada and Utah compared (Nevada AB 406). casrai.org/compare/ai-therapy-laws-illinois-nevada-utah-compared ; Wilson Sonsini (summary). Utah enacts mental health chatbot law (HB 452). Mar 2025. wsgr.com/en/insights/utah-enacts-mental-health-chatbot-law.html

See all sources

Source 214

American Psychological Association. Health advisory on AI chatbots and wellness apps for mental health. 13 Nov 2025. apa.org/news/press/releases/2025/11/ai-wellness-apps-mental-health

See all sources

Source 218

LBC. NHS warning on AI chatbots for mental health support. Dec 2025. lbc.co.uk/news/health/nhs-warning-ai-chatbots-mental-health

See all sources

Source 216

Illinois Department of Financial and Professional Regulation. Gov. Pritzker signs legislation prohibiting AI therapy in Illinois (HB 1806). Aug 2025. idfpr.illinois.gov/content/soi/idfpr/en/news/2025/gov-pritzker-signs-state-leg-prohibiting-ai-therapy-in-il.html

See all sources